Wrong testis removed

Medical History

A 46-year-old man consulted a surgeon privately because of a right inguinal hernia. At examination the surgeon decided that the left testis was normal but that the right testis was undescended. He advised that, if accessible, the right testis should be removed during the planned hernia repair to preclude the possibility of malignant change. An operation was performed.

Postoperatively it became clear that the right testis, which had been removed was normal, but this had not been recognised by the surgeon. The patient was left with a high and undescended left testis, which was probably non-functional and possibly susceptible to malignant change.

The patient was very distressed by what had taken place. He developed symptoms of post-traumatic stress disorder together with all the physical and psychological effects of castration. His depression and suicidal tendencies could be controlled only with difficulty, and he was totally unable to return to any form of employment.

Claim settled

The inevitable claim was settled for a sum that reflected carefully quantified compensation for the loss of future earnings.

This page was correct at publication on 01/01/2002. Any guidance is intended as general guidance for members only. If you are a member and need specific advice relating to your own circumstances, please contact one of our advisers.

You may also be interested in

Case study

Abnormal results missed

Two doctors failed to check the results of a blood test which resulted in delay in diagnosis of muscular dystrophy.

Read more
Case study

Unpredictable complication of surgery

A patient developed a CVA after hip replacement surgery.

Read more
Case study

Detached retina

A GP failed to diagnose a retinal detachment resulting in irreversible visual loss.

Read more