MDU welcomes pledge for increased consistency from ombudsman

The MDU has responded to today’s publication by the PHSO of a review of how it uses clinical advice when investigating complaints.

Responding to today's publication by the Parliamentary and Health Service Ombudsman of a review of how it uses clinical advice when investigating complaints, the MDU welcomed the announcement of a more consistent and clear approach to sharing the content of expert clinical advice with those complained about. This will be done at an early stage, before a provisional view is issued.

The qualifications and experience of the ombudsman's clinical adviser will also be made clear to those involved in a complaint, which should help ensure only those with the appropriate skills are appointed to provide expert advice.

However, the MDU explained that a key issue remains precisely how the Ombudsman's clinical advisers weigh up whether the clinical standard was acceptable or not.

Dr Michael Devlin, MDU head of professional standards and liaison, said:

'We are disappointed that the review did not accept our submission that the clinical standard should be that of reasonable and responsible practice. This represents a lost opportunity to provide clarity on the judgement clinical experts must apply.

'We note that in the future the ombudsman will publish examples of how the clinical standard has been applied, and we hope that this will provide some much-needed practical detail and help doctors to have confidence in the process.'

This guidance was correct at publication 21/03/2019. It is intended as general guidance for members only. If you are a member and need specific advice relating to your own circumstances, please contact one of our advisers.

You may also be interested in

Guidance and advice

Cautionary Tales 2018

The cases in our 2018 Cautionary Tales, based on MDU files, cover a wide range of specialties and situations, illustrating how we offer assistance to members when they need it most.

Read more
Journal

MDU journal spring 2018

Injuries from weapons such as knives, guns or even crossbows can raise questions over confidentiality and a doctor's duty to contact the authorities.

Read more
Journal

MDU journal summer 2017

Members of the MDU's expert team share their top tips on risk-management and traversing some common medico-legal issues.

Read more